The bar owner said the landlord was evicting them over noise issues, but an attorney for the landlord said the bar owner had failed to pay rent.

By Katelyn Umholtz December 16, 2024
3 minutes to read
Whitney’s in Harvard Square is closing at the end of the month after more than 70 years in business, according to a press release on Friday sent out by Whitney’s.
Owner Dan McGuire said the bar was handed an eviction notice by landlord Mayhaw, LLC because of the bar’s “daytime noise level” being an issue.
According to the press release, Whitney’s ownership was notified about their eviction back in June, and in those six months McGuire tried to remediate the noise issue with the landlord before the restaurant and bar was given a final eviction notice of Dec. 31.
“Whitney’s has always played music in accordance with our entertainment license, and we have never had to meet with the City of Cambridge and its license commission for any noise complaint,” McGuire, owner of Whitney’s for six years, said in the press release. “We’re beginning to think ‘noise’ truly cannot be the reason for wanting us to leave, and leave in such a hurry, after our repeated assurances that we would keep the volume down.

In a statement received from other news outlets, Mayhaw’s attorney Lori A. Drayton said the eviction notice was actually handed out over the bar’s “failure to pay any rent since October 2023, not due to any noise issues.” Boston.com reached out to Drayton for a statement and more information but didn’t hear back in time for publication.
On Monday publicist Dominic Amenta told Boston.com the situation has turned into a “he said, she said” dispute and that Mayhaw’s claim of Whitney’s owing rent wasn’t true. McGuire said he withheld paying rent for a three-month period over power enhancements that Mayhaw had promised to do for Whitney’s, but didn’t follow through despite making upgrades at other properties.
McGuire said he and the landlord had worked well together up until the power upgrade issue. A complaint was filed by Mayhaw in August of this year against McGuire’s Fat Heady, LLC, which ended in an agreement that Whitney’s would not have to pay owed rent in the amount of $44,800 if it didn’t play music before 6:30 p.m. and closed before Jan. 1, 2025.
Ultimately, McGuire claimed it came down to the fact that Mayhaw ownership wasn’t “happy with the images and sounds coming out of my business.”
McGuire also said that Mayhaw, owned by billionaire Gerald Chan, had moved into the upstairs unit in the building where Whitney’s resides at 37 John F. Kennedy St.
Other Harvard Square properties owned by Chan include the Harvard Square Theatre and the Dickson Bros. True Value hardware store, both which have sat vacant for years.
Whitney’s has been viewed as an institution in Harvard Square, inviting students and locals to the neighborhood bar for darts, hot dogs, and beer since it opened in 1953. It’s frequently packed with customers, especially on weekends and during events like the Harvard-Yale game.
The bar is also an example of what Harvard Square used to be, while its neighbors — chains like Warby Parker and salad spot SweetGreen — show what the square has become.
Before McGuire owned Whitney’s, it had been a spot he frequented.
“It was a place that was always there. It became a part of my life,” McGuire said. “Then I had the opportunity to buy it, to maintain a piece of community.”
Denise Jillson, executive director of the Harvard Square Business Association, said the news of Whitney’s looming closure was disappointing, but that she’s hopeful something can be worked out between the landlord and the longtime small business.
“We’re hopeful we can still resolve this problem and move forward,” Jillson said. “Frankly, of any property owner in the Square, this property owner has the capacity to do just that. One would hope this property owner would be more than willing to make the effort for a small, locally-owned business that has been beloved for over 70 years.”
McGuire said he plans to speak at the City Council meeting Monday evening about the closure, if not to help save Whitney’s, then to help other small, locally-owned businesses in Cambridge who may later face a similar fate. Mayor E. Denise Simmons sponsored a late resolution that urges “property owner Gerald Chan to grant a reprieve to Whitney’s beyond the December 31 eviction date to allow for meaningful dialogue and negotiation that could yet preserve this historic establishment.”